Piedoom0's audio Reviews on Newgrounds

[Thunder [Dubstep]]

er...

Are those vocals supposed to be comedic? Truthfully, the bass is very similar to many dubstep songs- it sounded as if you were trying to copy others than make up your own new style. But I guess good for what it is.

Itchimaru-kun responds:

I appreciate the feedback, however, I don't think a song should always be measured by "how much of a NEW style it is". It is nearly impossible to invent a new style these days, so I take the fact that you think it sounds like "stylistic dubstep" as a compliment cause that is what I was going for...

[WHO YOU GOT?]

...

I'm not sure how to respond to this.
But I can't stop listening to it
;;

facebagel responds:

Well, you could tell me who you have for social studies first and formost ;)

[Hunted Hunter - WIP]

ffffs

Completely amazing. Great drumline. And that guitar in the beginning gave me an eargasm, such a lovely voice. Pro-quality stuff, I can see this in a game. Can I ask what program/plugins you used for that wonderful guitar at 0:20?

SFaPiL2 responds:

Thanks for the compliments ^_^.

The guitars used here were real, not plugins. I used Guitar Rig Mobile to record myself playing and then I used the Guitar Rig essential plugin to give it some reverbs, delays, amps and the like.

[-586rick- Thinking Mode]

alright

You have some ways to go, but you've got your basics down. Drums sounded wonderful and your bassline was suitable. I just felt that so much more could have been done with the lead voice... it just seemed like a typewriter, spitting out similar notes at the same tempo and velocity.

586rick responds:

I see what you mean, like I said its only something that pass my head. thanks for the review.

[Sweet Dreams (Hardstyle Remix)]

herp

Truthfully, I didn't enjoy the first theme. But once you started changing it up I really got into it. Great drums, synths, and effects. Overall a great song.
I assume you use FLS?

Zodin responds:

Thanks, i guess :)
Yup i do.

[Destroying Tetris]

LOLWUT.jpg

This was one of the... odder songs. I enjoyed it nonetheless. Great 8-bit voices, though I think you could have mastered them better, made some drum noises less noisy. This was really creative, and a really cool song overall :D

clock-work responds:

Thanks! :D

I could of mastered them better, but I'm to lazy xD

I also have a newer version with the middle a bit more.. mastered (:p) on the way...

*Which is now replacing the old version :P

[Chocolate Space]

Well this was a very happy industrial song...

I liked it overall... it was kind of cliched and boring at some parts though. I loved the way the lead voice was. It sounded so whiny, but in a good way... like a lively way xD. I would dispute this being industrial, though o-O

marlgryd responds:

Thanks for the comment!! I really appreciate it. Yap, the song is indeed quite boring - I totally agree with that, but I was tired, it was late at night, so I just finished where I was and posted.

[Pugilator]

wonderful

Just beautifully constructed, all around wonderful. I loved the beginning, middle, and end. You should know I rarely give out 10 stars. Thanks for uploading this wonderful piece.
...and FLS ftw.

RunningShadows responds:

Thanks! I'm glad you enjoyed it so much as to give it a 10. I am quite honored. FLS is win.

[[sc] silent monolith]

---

when it was over... I was all "NUHHH I MUST KNOW HOW THIS PROGRESSES."
It sounded like you were creating a song to go along with a book.
I really want you to go ahead and make this longer, I bet it will be pretty awesome.

SilentCortex responds:

the answer lies within your silent self.....
just use your imagination for this is only the beginning........
-sc-

[[dj-Jo] 3 Towers (Synergy Mix)]

---

pretty cool :D Actually got chills at the 0:18 drum cut-in. You changed up the rhythm and style enough for it to be a bit refreshing, though I wish you would have changed the melody as well (although since this is a remix, I'm not sure if you were allowed to.) Additionally, when you held the lead voices for a long time, I wish you added some modulation to them instead of the pitch just being lifeless. Other than that, I loved the concept and ESPECIALLY the drums. Good luck on the contest as well.

dj-Jo responds:

About the modulation...
Thats not a bad idea :D

Thanks for the constructive criticism as well

Also, bout the melody, I tried not to keep too fair away from the original so that's why it's the way it is.

Thanks again for the review
It always helps!